Choosing the right type of glass for your commercial greenhouse project
Articles
When building a commercial greenhouse, there are many factors to consider including LED lights, heating systems, cooling systems, vents, screens and most importantly, glass.
As the majority of a glasshouse’s construction consists of glass, the specific material used can have a major impact on plant growth and crop yield.
There are also other considerations such as safety, energy efficiency and cost which are all affected by the type of glass that is used in the commercial greenhouse – whether it’s for growers, garden centres or research organisations.
As experts in greenhouses and renewable energy, we’re taking a look at the different types of glass that can be used and their features and benefits.
Why does the type of glass used matter so much?
Different types of glass possess a range of different qualities. There is no one-size-fits-all solution, so it is important to know what your essential requirements are whilst still working within your budget.
When choosing the right glass, the challenge is to find the optimal balance between:
- Light transmission
- Energy efficiency (A lower U-Value is better)
- Solar heat control
- Light diffusion
- Safety and security
- Condensation management
- Budget
Equipment such as vent and screen motors, LED lights, heating elements and fans can also cause shading which results in reduced crop yields, therefore, every bit of light that can transmit through the glass becomes so important.
What types of glass are there for commercial greenhouses?
4mm Horticultural Float Glass
4mm Horticultural Float Glass has historically been the industry standard in UK greenhouses as it typically provides the best balance between light transmission and low cost.
It provides a high light transmission of around 89%-90% but one downside of the standard float glass is its poor energy performance, possessing a U-Value of ~5.7 W/m²K. It is also the most fragile of all the options, shattering into large sharp shards when broken. It should therefore not be used for research or public occupation glasshouses.
- 4mm Horticultural Tempered Float Glass
The tempered alternative is the standard in the Netherlands as it provides all the same benefits, including 89%-90% light transmission with no coatings. However, it is up to 5x stronger than regular float glass.
Even if the glass does break, it splinters into thousands of tiny blunt pieces instead of large sharp shards, making Tempered Float Glass a much safer option.
These major benefits are met with slightly higher costs and an increase risk of shattering during extreme hot weather.
A heat soak test can be conducted to quality control the tempered glass and mitigate the risk of spontaneous breakage but it can come at an extra cost.
- Diffused Glass
Diffused glass can provide a range of benefits for specific plants due to its ability to scatter incoming sunlight. This allows the light to penetrate deeper in the lower canopy of high wire crops such as tomatoes.
Having more light shine on more leaves throughout the canopies increases the rate of photosynthesis which in turn increases yields. A reduction in plant stress has also been witnessed with the use of diffused glass.
The light diffusion is particularly effective in alleviating the consequences of shading from high level infrastructure such as overhead vents, lights and fans, again increasing yields.
Naturally there is an extra capital cost associated with diffused glass. Also diffusing is always present, so other less permanent solutions might be preferred if there is a chance of changing crop or growing techniques in the future.
As a result of diffusion, light transmission rates reduce by ~0.5%-1% depending on the degree of hazing. However, this loss of light can be mitigated with the use of antireflective (AR) coatings which is discussed later in the article, but these also come with an increase in the costs.
- Low-Iron Glass
Low-iron Glass is essentially an extra clear version of traditional float glass, produced by reducing the amount of iron oxide present within the glass. It retains all the positives of float glass but with an increased light transmission of 2% – giving it a light transmission rate of 91%.
Due to the high price, for relatively small light transmission gains, low iron glass is generally only used at the highest level of commercial growing where the maximum amount of light is needed.
AR coatings can also produce similar results on standard float glass at a reduced price, meaning low-iron glass is used sparingly in select projects.
- Low-E Geysir Glass
Geysir Glass is designed to reflect thermal radiation using a microscopically thin pyrolytic low emissivity (Low-E) coating that traps heat inside. The Low-E coating acts as a mirror so rising heat bounces back instead of escaping the greenhouse.
Low-E Geysir glass has a U Value of 3.7 W/m²K, a much lower rate of heat transfer in comparison to float glass at 5.7 W/m²K. The low emissivity coating also reduces condensation resulting in more light being let in and when paired with a double anti-reflective coating, Geysir Glass matches normal float glass in light transmission.
Due to its effectiveness at retaining heat, it can sometimes cause overheating in summer and is more costly than standard glass. However, it can be ideal for smaller research projects.
The high cost of Geysir Glass relative to standard horticultural glass types, often means that it is not viable for large scale commercial projects. However it is being considered more and more often on smaller projects, and on research facilities etc.
- Laminated Safety Glass
For extra protection for workers, delicate crops and sensitive equipment, laminated safety glass is sometimes considered. Laminated safety glass is created by bonding a tough sticky plastic layer in between two panes of glass.
In addition to having the strength of tempered glass, it can help maintain the seal when a pane is broken, keeping rain, wind and pests out until it can be replaced.
Laminated safety glass is reserved for specific circumstances as it is very expensive and can only be incorporated in bespoke structures as it is not viable in standard Venlo glazing systems.
- Double Glazing
Double glazing has a very low U-Value at 2.6 W/m²K, reduces condensation and improves climate stability by minimising temperature fluctuations.
The energy saving comes at a price as it is more expensive due to increased weight and subsequent need for a heavy-duty structure. Another consequence includes a light transmission rate of 83% as opposed to 90% from float glass.
- Polycarbonate (16mm and 10mm)
Glass is not the only material that can be used in greenhouses. Polycarbonate is a transparent thermoplastic polymer which provides many benefits that glass cannot replicate.
The 16mm form of polycarbonate has a very high energy saving with a U-Value of 2.5W/m²K and is extremely impact resistant. They are produced in large sheets which reduces shade from the glazing system and make them easier to use for high-containment facilities when studying high-risk plant pathogens, exotic pests, or GMOs for example.
It is more expensive than glass, and has a reduced light transmission of 74% at 16mm thickness. It is therefore generally considered where high safety standards, or high containment is required, or if the crop does not need high light levels. Polycarbonate blocks almost all UV light, however trials indicate that enough UV is transmitted to retain healthy plant growth.
- Polythene Film
Polythene film generally has a lower initial capital cost compared to other options discussed. Standard clear films provide a high light transmission of around 88% to 90%. Also modern polythene films can be manufactured with specific chemical additives to replicate the benefits of more expensive glass treatments. These include light-diffusing properties to improve lower canopy penetration, and anti-condensation (AC) additives that prevent water droplets from reflecting light and dripping onto crops.
Due to UV degradation and general exposure to the elements, the film typically requires replacing every 4 to 15 years (depending on material and quality of installation). While the initial material cost is low, this replacement cycle introduces ongoing labour and maintenance costs which need to be considered. Polythene is also vulnerable to physical damage such as tearing or bird damage, which also needs to be factored into the maintenance costs.
There are many types of film, but one stand out product is ETFE, which has a very high light transmission of up to 95%, and can last over 20 years if installed correctly, however the very high cost of EFTE film needs to be factored.
A single layer of polythene has a relatively poor U-Value and offers minimal thermal retention. Growers can mitigate this by installing a double-skinned, air-inflated polythene roof. This creates an insulating pocket of air that dramatically improves heat retention by around 30%, although there is a resulting small drop in overall light transmission.
Alternative solutions and additions to improve performance from greenhouse glass
The glass selected is not the only important consideration when specifying a new commercial greenhouse. Here are some alternative solutions that can work in conjunction with many of the materials mentioned, often used to increase light transmission or affect the light that enters:
- Anti-Reflective Coating
Standard glass and condensation droplets can reflect sunlight. This can be mitigated by coating the panes with anti-reflective (AR) and anti-condensation (AC) coatings.
AR coatings can reclaim 2%-4% of light transmission for each side of glass, and are often used to offset lost transmission from diffused glass or other glass treatments.
If AR coating is used on the internal and external surfaces of the glasshouse (Double AR) then the overall light transmission can be increased by up to 8%.
- Anti-Condensation Coating
AC coatings use hydrophilic action to force water into a thin, transparent film that channels it to gutters. This stops light reflecting via condensation and prevents water droplets from dripping onto plants which can often elevate the risk of fungus growth and disease.
- Glass Spray-on Coatings
There are a wide variety of different spray-on coatings that can be applied to produce different effects including light diffusion, solar heat reduction, solar shading and photo selection which can selectively filter, reflect or absorb specific wavelengths.
Spray-on coatings are a more temporary solution as they need to be reapplied regularly, but this can be beneficial for those who want to change coatings between seasons or if they want to test out different effects.
As a permanent solution, they are not as effective due to the recurring annual cost and potential inconsistencies when applying it to the glass panes.
- Clear/Diffused Energy Screen Systems
Screens can be a great addition to greenhouses , because they can be used during the day with minimal shading to maximise crop growth, while providing energy savings in the region of 47%.
If a diffused cloth is used, it gives the grower the flexibility to choose when they want diffused light, if they do not want to commit to diffused glass.
Trapped humidity can occur but it can be resolved if the screen is gapped correctly for ventilation. They also need to be replaced every 10-15 years depending on algae growth and general wear and tear.
The future of glass in commercial greenhouses
New innovations for commercial growers are constantly being developed. Scientific breakthroughs in glass technology are finding ways to improve energy efficiency, increase the rate of photosynthesis, replace existing technology and utilise renewable energy.
Here are a few newer technologies that are likely to make a big impact in the future:
- Vacuum Insulated Glass
Vacuum insulated glass consists of two panes separated by a vacuum, emulating the same insulation values as triple-glazing but in a thinner form. With a U-Value of 0.7 W/m²K, it is seen as one of the most promising technologies for next-generation energy-neutral greenhouses.
- Quantum Dot Technology
An innovative luminescent film that absorbs inefficient UV light and converts it into highly efficient wavelengths that can increase crop yields.
- Agrivoltaics & Building-Integrated Photovoltaics (BIPV)
Photovoltaic materials can replace roofs, facades or windows (in the case of greenhouses) to generate renewable electricity which can help offset LED and heating costs.
- Smart Dynamic Glass
An architectural glass that can actively change the tint via an electrical current to provide instant shading. This could replace the need for screens.
Need help choosing the right greenhouse for your project?
As specialists in constructing and equipping commercial greenhouses, Bridge Greenhouses can help you through every step of the journey from design and construction to providing equipment and support.
Whether you need a greenhouse for commercial growing or research and study, our 40 years’ experience in the horticultural industry will help you figure out what solution works best for you.